FUNDAMENTAL TRUTH #45: “The bluest of cities in the bluest of states have the most activist governments, the deepest recessions and the most abject poverty.” -Old Pithy

Posted by PITHOCRATES - December 21st, 2010

Blue States Bleeding Red

We call it the Great Recession.  It started with the subprime mortgage crisis.  Then the dominoes started falling.  And unemployment rates started to climb.  So many people lost their jobs that it wasn’t only banks and auto companies staring into the abyss of bankruptcy.  Our city and states were, too.

But not all our cities and states.  Some were hanging in there during the Great Recession.  There was a pattern.  Sure, it was a rule with some exceptions, but a general rule all the same.  And if you looked at one of those red/blue electoral maps, you could see the states (and the cities) having the biggest financial troubles.  You just looked for the blue.

The blue states are the ‘Democrat’ states.  The red states are ‘Republican’.  And the states that are in the news with financial troubles tend to be the blue states.  The New England States.  The Mid-West states.  And the West Coast states.  The rate of business failures and high unemployment rates have hammered these states.  Taxable income plummeted.  Without the income to tax, tax revenue plummeted.  And these blue states are bleeding red.

Blue States and Unionized Public Sector Employees

These are the Big Government states.  Home for most of the nation’s liberal democrats.  Although liberal democrats make up only about 20% of the national population, most of them live in these states.  And when you pack a lot of this 20% into these small areas, their influence can reach a majority.  And they can control these cities and states.  And do.

These liberals are the guilty rich (anti-capitalist inheritors of great wealth).  Crony-capitalists (anti-capitalists who eschew the free market and bribe politicians in exchange for governmental favoritism).  Big Union (anti-capitalists who eschew the free market and seek legislation that favors them).  The celebrity rich (anti-capitalist movie stars, musicians, painters, artists, etc., who don’t live in the real world).  University professors (anti-capitalists who still have posters of Che Guevara up in their classrooms).  The mainstream media (anti-capitalists who want to shape opinion instead of practicing journalism).  And, of course, the poor and government-dependent.

And then you have public sector employees.  Unionized public sector employees.  And their ranks are growing.  They don’t work very hard.  But boy are they paid well.  And talk about fat benefits.  Pension plans that most can’t even imagine.  They have made themselves a privileged class.  And with their boss having the power to tax, that privileged class will be remaining privileged for a long time to come.  Unless a Great Recession comes along.

Much of Flyover Country not having any Budget Crises

What is flyover country?  It’s that are area of the country liberals fly over when traveling between the West Coast, the Big Union Mid-West, New England and, of course, Washington D.C.  It’s that area in between.  The red states.  You see, liberals fly over the red states because they don’t like them.  Or Republicans.

Because America is a center-right nation, and the liberals have concentrated in the blue states, that has left most of ‘fly over’ country conservative.  And what do conservatives NOT like?  Big Government.  So liberals don’t go where they’ve not welcomed.  For Big Government is the heart and soul of liberalism.

So the red states don’t have Big Government.  They don’t have masses of government-dependent people.  And they don’t have large public sectors.  Or public sector union employees.  Which means they don’t have huge Big Government budgets.  Or budget crises.

The Public Sector Out Paces the Private Sector in the Blue States

But the blue states do.  Their Big Cities are packed with government-dependent people.  And they have a huge public sector to cater to these people.  And a public sector union that pays this public sector very well.  They have pay and benefit packages that are to die for.

Of course, a public sector doesn’t make anything.  They have no goods or services that they can sell in the free market.  They have but one source of income.  Taxes.  And when times are good, taxes are good.  But when times are poor, so are taxes.

Part of the liberal democrat’s strategy to remain in power is to get as many people as possible dependent on government.  This helps make Democrat voters (people who vote Democrat because they are afraid of losing their government benefits).  And justifies their huge government budgets.  So they keep adding people to the public dole.  And keep growing their budgets.  It’s a foolproof plan.  As long as the private sector grows along with the public sector.  So the private sector can keep paying the taxes to support the public sector.  And the privileged class.

Big Government – The Road to Bankruptcy

But it doesn’t always work.  When businesses fail they don’t have any income.  So they can’t pay any income taxes.  And when a business fails people lose their jobs.  And their incomes.  So they don’t pay any income taxes either.  But it doesn’t end there.  Without any income, they can’t buy anything in the free market.  So other businesses see their sales decline.  And have to lay off employees.  And these laid-off people can’t buy anything in the free market.  So more businesses see their sales decline.  And they lay off people.  And on and on it goes.  Where does it stop?  Usually in a bad recession.  Or even a great one.

You add all of this up and what do you get?  Big cities with growing budgets (and growing pension obligations).  And shrinking tax revenue to pay for it.  Costs exceed revenues.  Ergo, bankruptcy.

And some of the states with the most generous public sector pay and benefits are California, Illinois and New York.   Some of the bluest of blue states.  And coincidentally, these are the states facing some of the biggest budget crises.  Actually, it’s no coincidence.  It’s the ultimate consequence of Big Government.  Bankruptcy.


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,