Birth Control and Abortion hurt the Welfare State because Babies become Taxpayers
People typically have fewer children during bad economic times. Because you have to feed and clothe kids. Which is very hard to do during bad economic times. Especially if you lost your job during a period of high unemployment. Such as the Great Depression. Or if you’re going through a period of high inflation. Like during the Seventies. We can see this if we look at the birthrate over the years.
(source: Population Reference Bureau)
Bad economic times (Great Depression) fewer births. High inflation (the Seventies) fewer births. Of course, there was something else happening during the Seventies. Which followed the Sexual Revolution. Women were having more sex outside of marriage. But they were using birth control and recently legalized abortion to avoid having children. Women were liberated. The feminists were moving into careers once reserved for men. And because they were having careers they were not being stay-at-home mothers raising a family.
Also during the Seventies there was the zero population growth movement. Among many other movements. As the hippies turned antiestablishment. And anti-capitalist. Preferring a communal life. Where there was no greed or profits. Where everyone was equal and had an equal share. Like the communists enjoyed. Or, rather, suffered. The zero population growth movement protested against having babies. And the threat they posed to the limited resources of the earth. So they were quite happy to see the birthrate fall below the replacement birthrate (about 2.1 children per woman in the United States). Because below this rate future generations will be smaller than previous generations. Which will burden the limited resources of the earth less. But it created a big problem for those who wanted a large socialist state to provide cradle to the grave welfare. For babies become taxpayers.
Because of the War on Poverty it takes Two Incomes to raise a Family Today
We just emerged from a government shutdown that ended with an agreement to raise the debt ceiling. Why? Because they can’t raise tax rates high enough to pay for all of the government’s spending. At least not without putting most everyone below the poverty line after taxes. Which makes that declining birthrate a big problem. For the fall in the birthrate coincided with the expansion of the welfare state in the Sixties. As can be seen in the explosion in welfare spending following LBJ’s launching of his War on Poverty.
(source: The Heritage Foundation)
So just as women were having fewer babies so following generations would be smaller LBJ’s Great Society gave us a new expanding welfare state. That is, once our tax base began to grow smaller with each subsequent generation federal expenditures were growing larger with each subsequent generation. Resulting in higher tax rates on the smaller tax base to pay for it. And massive new borrowings to pay what our taxes won’t. As the government took more of our earnings away median household income stagnated.
(source: The Heritage Foundation)
If you’ve ever wondered why we can’t raise a family on one income these days this is why. It’s the growth of federal spending. Paid for with a growth in tax revenue. Leaving us less money to raise our families. Requiring that second income. This is what the Great Society gave us. And it’s what birth control and abortion gave us. But it gets worse.
This Year Adult Incontinence Pants outsold Baby Diapers in Japan for the First Time
The Sexual Revolution gave us a baby bust generation. Following a baby boom generation. Giving us an aging population. Where more people are leaving the workforce than are entering it. So more people are consuming taxes (Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) than are paying taxes. Causing a massive wealth transfer from the young to the old. So an aging population makes it even harder to raise a family. Especially for the young just starting their families. Because of the higher tax rates on a shrinking workforce required to pay for that aging population. Which can lead to worse things than a collapse of the welfare state (see Why have young people in Japan stopped having sex? by Abigail Haworth posted 10/19/2013 on The Guardian)
Japan’s under-40s appear to be losing interest in conventional relationships. Millions aren’t even dating, and increasing numbers can’t be bothered with sex. For their government, “celibacy syndrome” is part of a looming national catastrophe. Japan already has one of the world’s lowest birth rates. Its population of 126 million, which has been shrinking for the past decade, is projected to plunge a further one-third by 2060…
Fewer babies were born here in 2012 than any year on record. (This was also the year, as the number of elderly people shoots up, that adult incontinence pants outsold baby nappies in Japan for the first time.) Kunio Kitamura, head of the JFPA, claims the demographic crisis is so serious that Japan “might eventually perish into extinction”.
This is the zero population growth movement on steroids. The Republicans in the United States shut down the government in an attempt to curtail federal spending. As the public debt is approaching 100% of GDP. Very dangerous territory to be in. But if you think that’s bad it’s far worse in Japan. As their public debt is approximately 214% of GDP. To support a massive welfare state. In a country where the taxpayer is fast becoming an endangered species.
This is the ultimate end of any democracy that learned it could vote itself the treasury. As taxes rise people cut back on their spending. And a big cost item is children. So we have declining birthrates in developed countries with expansive welfare states. And immigration problems. Immigrants who come for those generous state benefits. And governments that want to grant them citizenship. To make them taxpayers. To make up for that declining birthrate. And prevent their own extinction.
Tags: abortion, aging population, babies, birth control, birthrate, births, children, declining birthrate, family, federal spending, Great Society, Japan, kids, public debt, sexual revolution, tax rates, taxpayer, war on poverty, welfare, welfare state, zero population growth, zero population growth movement