The Labor Force Participation Rate has Fallen Steadily since President Obama became President
Ever since the recovery summer of 2010 the Obama administration has told us the recession was over. And his policies were creating one heck of an economic recovery. Backed up by all those glowing monthly jobs reports. Like the December 2013 jobs report (see Employment Situation Summary posted 1/10/2014 on the Bureau of Labor Statistics).
The unemployment rate declined from 7.0 percent to 6.7 percent in December, while total nonfarm payroll employment edged up (+74,000), the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today.
The unemployment rate is down. And new jobs were created. Again. Jobs report after jobs report it’s the same thing. The administration touts the falling unemployment rate and new job creation as confirmation that their economic policies are working. Even though it’s been 5 years. And the economy is still in the toilet. Despite that falling unemployment rate. For there is a reason why the unemployment rate is falling. And it has nothing to do with an economic activity.
The civilian labor force participation rate declined by 0.2 percentage point to 62.8 percent in December… The labor force participation rate declined by 0.8 percentage point over the year…
In fact, the labor force participation rate has fallen steadily since President Obama became president. This is not good. In fact, it’s very bad. Because it means that under President Obama’s economic policies more people have left the labor force than entered or remained in it. Meaning that his economic policies have caused a net loss of jobs throughout his presidency.
The U-6 Unemployment Rate is Closer to the Bitter Sentiment of Job Seekers in the Current Economic Climate
In January of 2009 when President Obama began his presidency there were 80,507,000 people not in the labor force. At the end of December 2013 that number grew to 91,808,000. Subtracting one from the other and you get 11,301,000 people that have left the labor force since President Obama entered office. Because his policies destroyed 11,301,000 jobs. And because these people couldn’t find new jobs they just gave up looking. Which is why the unemployment rate keeps falling.
So you can talk of new jobs created. And a falling unemployment rate. But those numbers don’t reflect the 11,301,000 jobs President Obama destroyed with his policies. Which comes to 260,200 jobs lost per year. Or 188,350 each month. Which is a lot more than the 74,000 new jobs. In fact, if you look at the change in the number of people not in the labor force from November to December of 2013 you’ll see that 525,000 people left the labor force. So the December jobs lost is about 2.8 times the average jobs lost during the Obama presidency. And giving a ratio of about 7 jobs lost for every new job created in December. Making December a horrible month for jobs. Much worse than the 6.7% unemployment rate would have us believe.
The funny thing about the official unemployment rate is that the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) doesn’t count people who quit looking for a job. Or who are working part-time because they can’t find a full-time job. If we want an alternative measure of labor underutilization (that counts more people who can’t find a full-time job) we should look at the U-6 unemployment rate. We can find this number in the same BLS jobs report (in Table A-15). Which was 13.1% for December 2013. An unemployment rate much closer to the bitter sentiment of job seekers in the current economic climate.
We will have to Wait through many more Bad Jobs Reports before we can Enjoy a Healthy Economy Again
The Employment Situation Summary confirms the horrible economy. Though misleading with these falling unemployment rates the real economic picture is still in these reports. All you have to do is look for them. And understand what they mean. For example:
In December, job gains occurred in retail trade and wholesale trade…
Employment in retail trade rose by 55,000 in December. Within the industry, job gains occurred in food and beverage stores (+12,000), clothing and accessories stores (+12,000), general merchandise stores (+8,000), and motor vehicle and parts dealers (+7,000)…
In December, wholesale trade added 15,000 jobs. Most of the job growth occurred in electronic markets and agents and brokers (+9,000).
Note that of the 74,000 new jobs 70,000 (94.6%) of them were in retail and wholesale trade. Which is not surprising when you consider what’s in December. Christmas. (While near-zero interest rates sold cars to people who would otherwise not buy them.) The final sprint of retailers for the year. And when many of them go firmly into the black. But while the Christmas surge on employment was underway other sectors did not fare as well.
Within the [professional and business services] industry, temporary help services added 40,000 jobs in December, while employment in accounting and bookkeeping services declined by 25,000.
Businesses add temporary workers when they have a surge in sales they believe won’t last. And don’t want to have more permanent workers on their payroll when that surge in sales ends. For it is easier to let temps go than full-time workers. And less costly. Accounting and bookkeeping services aren’t the most glamorous of services. When the economy is growing businesses have more accounting and bookkeeping work. But when the economy is contracting businesses have less accounting and bookkeeping work. So a decline here could indicate an economic contraction.
The December 2013 jobs report is bleak. Just as the oncoming winter looks in December. Knowing we’ll have to wait through a long and cold winter before we can enjoy the warmth of summer again. Just as we know we will have to wait through many more bad jobs reports before we can enjoy a healthy economy again. Thanks to the horrific economic policies of the Obama administration that have failed to work these past 5 years.
Tags: BLS, December, economic policies, economic recovery, economy, Employment Situation Summary, full-time, job creation, jobs, jobs reports, labor force, labor force participation rate, Obama administration, part-time, President Obama, recession, retail trade, unemployment rate, wholesale trade