China has Severe Inequality and the Worst Public Toilets in all of Asia

Posted by PITHOCRATES - September 8th, 2012

Week in Review

The Left believes the government can make capitalism better.  And fairer.  In the Eighties they liked to point to Japan.  And the incredible economic growth they had thanks to government partnering with business.  Before their deflationary spiral and their Lost Decade.  Thanks to all that government partnering with business.  But that was yesterday’s news.  Today they like to point at the economic juggernaut that is China.  And say, “See?  That’s what strong government can do.”  For they believe China can get things done because they don’t have to deal with that pesky democracy.  All of those elections.   And being answerable to the people.  In China the government rules.  And the people quake in their boots.  Which lets China get things done.  And make a better society for all Chinese (see The forbidden public toilets of Beijing by Justin Rowlatt posted 9/8/2012 on BBC News Magazine).

Jeff Sun is the scion of one of China’s new rich and the founder of the “China Super Car Club”. He has got so many he cannot even remember them all…

We met Jeff while reporting on the yawning chasms of inequality that have opened up in Chinese society.

We filmed in some of the poorest communities I have ever visited – Chinese villages where no-one has ever owned a car and where they still till their fields using a single donkey, shared between dozens of farmers.

A better society for all Chinese?  Granted there are those on the Left who would love to see a world where no one owned a car.  But one donkey shared between dozens of farmers?  That doesn’t sound like a fairer society.  Not when there are rich people elsewhere who have so many cars that they can’t remember them all.  So apparently this state-capitalism (or as they say in China, communism) isn’t as egalitarian as the Left would like to believe.  For in America there is more capitalism than communism.  And yet American farmers don’t share donkeys.  No.  In America farmers own their own tractors.  Which seems to be a bit more egalitarian than communist China.  But it gets worse.

The journalists’ rule of thumb is that you cannot report the so-called three Ts – Tiananmen, Taiwan or Tibet.

We inadvertently discovered a fourth T.

In an article in the country’s English language newspaper, China Daily, I came across an editorial featuring stinging criticism of China from the WTO. Not the World Trade Organisation, this was the less well-known World Toilet Organisation.

This WTO had ranked China as having the worst public toilets in all Asia. The paper explained how, in response, Beijing had introduced rigorous new hygiene standards – now no more than two flies are now allowed in any public toilet.

The paper was in no doubt about the importance of the issue. “Clean public toilets are the symbol of a civilized society,” it thundered. The controversy made me chuckle and I mentioned to our government minder that I wanted to cover this storm in a toilet bowl.

It was Mr Chen’s job to ensure we did not break any reporting rules. He had been a cheerful, relaxed companion throughout our three-week journey, but now his face darkened.

“I do not think that would be a good idea,” he said gravely…

Mr Chen vanished for a few moments. When he returned his manner was forbidding.

“I am sorry Justin but I have to tell you cannot report this story at all.”

The human rights issue of Tiananmen, Taiwan or Tibet may be a sore spot for China as well as the liberals who so admire their way of governing.  But the worst public toilets in all Asia?  That affects everyone.  At least those who have to drop trou in their busy day away from home.  Not to mention the tourists.  The Chinese government may not know a good, quality public toilet but people traveling to their country no doubt do.  Oh the shame.  Oh the humanity.  Oh the inequality.  No wonder the sensors will allow journalists to report about the severe inequality in Chinese society.  For what is a village of farmers having to share one donkey compared to embarrassing public toilets?  For we all know every country judges another by the quality of their public toilets.  For few things are so sacred, so personal, as copping a squat when out on the town.

And this is the governing style the Left would have the US follow.  For it is more egalitarian.  Even though the masses must use the worse public toilets in all of Asia while the new Chinese rich no doubt enjoy a squat on the finest porcelain known to mankind.  And probably follow that up with a refreshing bidet cleansing.  No.  This isn’t equality.  This is a toilet aristocracy.  Which simply doesn’t exist under laissez faire capitalism.  Where going to the toilet in public isn’t a privilege.  It’s just so expected in capitalist societies that it is taken for granted.

www.PITHOCRATES.com

Share

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Blog Home