Japan’s Future is Bleak thanks to their Welfare State and their Aging Population

Posted by PITHOCRATES - April 28th, 2012

Week in Review

Japan made two great mistakes since World War II.  Establishing a great welfare state.  And interfering into the private sector economy during the Eighties.  Causing a great asset bubble.  And a deflationary spiral lasting a decade or two.  Which has compounded their first mistake (see As Japan strains to care for elderly, sacrifices begin by Chico Harlan posted 4/28/2012 on The Washington Post).

In recent months, Prime Minister Yoshihiko Noda has staked his job and bet his support on a tax increase designed to fund Japan’s soaring social security costs.

And the potential tax hike is only a sneak preview of the burdens to come as Japan grows into the world’s grayest society, a nation where two decades from now seniors will outnumber children 15 and younger by nearly 4 to 1.

Economists and government officials say that Japan, in the coming years, will probably raise the retirement age, again increase taxes and trim spending on everything from education to defense, all to care for its elderly.

Young Japanese — those entering the workforce amid two decades of stagnation — will face the greatest burden: They will earn less in real terms than their parents, pay higher pension premiums, receive fewer social services and, eventually, retire with a less-generous pension package.

Talk about inverting the pyramid.  Which is what social security is.  A pyramid scheme.  Which will work as long as those entering the scheme outnumber those collecting benefits from the scheme.  Because everyone pays a little to support the big consumers at the top.  But what happens when the big consumers at the top outnumber those paying into the system 4 to 1?  You suffer.  And sacrifice.  With a capital ‘s’.  Especially those at the bottom.  Who will pay in more than those at the top ever did.  While only collecting a fraction of their benefits.  If they collect anything at all.

This is the problem an aging population causes a spendthrift government.  You simply can’t spend at a greater rate than the rate your population is growing.  Because all government spending has to be financed by the taxpayers.  Those with jobs.  In the private sector.  So if the population growth rate falls (i.e., the population is aging) the tax contributions from the individual taxpayers must increase.  Basically enslaving the younger generation to the older generation.  The lesson of Japan should be a cautionary tale to governments everywhere.  For it will happen to you if you try to be too generous with your state benefits.

As it rose into an economic power after World War II, Japan created a generous social security net, with a universal health-care system and a universal pension system in which people were covered as employees or via a basic national program. But since the collapse two decades ago of the real estate and stock market bubble, the foundation of that system has started to crack. Tax revenue has dropped amid deflation, forcing Japan, whose debt-to-GDP ratio is highest among developed countries, to fund its social programs with more and more borrowing…

Kakuta [a 20-year-old college student] said he didn’t think the cutbacks to the current system were coming fast enough. And he doubted the ability of Japanese politicians to draft the right policies.

“To me,” he said, “it sounds more and more like we’re passing this on to the younger people. . . . I feel especially bad for the generation after mine. And that certainly doesn’t motivate me to have more children.”

Who would want to burden their children with a life of near-subsistence?  So it is not surprising that the younger generation may not have the same number of children that their parents did.  Which is the worst thing possible for the government.  For there will be fewer people entering the workforce.  While the population of those leaving the workforce will grow ever larger.  Making the burden on the young even greater.  For each individual will have to support more retirees.  The retirees will, in effect, become their children.

The U.S. is following the Japanese.  For we already know Social Security and Medicare are going bankrupt.  And now with Obamacare thrown in the mix the U.S. will run to catch up with Japan.  As the Europeans are trying to do as well.  Perhaps heralding the end of Western Civilization.  As we turn the hands of time back.  To when there was a ruling elite and impoverished masses.  Who will work for no one but the state.  In exchange for their meager state allowance.

Marx and Engels had it all wrong.  You don’t destroy the middle class with a revolution of the working class.  You do it with the welfare state.  And let the middle class destroy themselves.  By demanding ever more from the welfare state.  It may take a little longer.  But it is so much easier to do.  All you have to do is give people lots of free stuff.  And the people will take it from there.  To the European sovereign debt crisis.  Or to something worse.  To something like that lurking in Japan’s future.

www.PITHOCRATES.com

Share

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments are closed.

Blog Home