FT93: “Those who don’t want to pay more taxes are greedy yet those who want more free benefits are not.” -Old Pithy

Posted by PITHOCRATES - November 25th, 2011

Fundamental Truth

Income Gaps are a Bad Thing when our Own Income is at the Low End of the Gap

Greed is a tricky word.  A lot of people say it’s bad to be greedy.  And a lot of people believe that it is.  There is a level of wealth out there.  If you’re below it and you want more it’s okay.  You’re not greedy.  If you’re above it and you want more then shame on you.  Because you’re greedy.  But can you name that line of wealth?  Probably not.  Why?  Because it isn’t a fixed amount.  It moves.  And it’s relative.

You see, we judge wealth by comparing another’s wealth to our own.  Anyone wealthier than we are already has enough and should not object to paying more income taxes.  So these taxes can buy more free government benefits for those not as wealthy.  Namely ourselves.  So we can have more without having to work any harder to get it.  For we believe income gaps are a bad thing.  At least when our own income is at the low end of the gap.  And we believe the government should level the playing field.  Make things fairer.  By redistributing the income of those who already have enough.  To those of us who don’t.

At least that’s the mentality.  Because few people in the world would ever believe that they already have too much.  Even rock stars and professional athletes who have more wealth than most could ever imagine believe this.  Because neither continues to play for free after earning ‘enough’ wealth.  And neither would ever consider themselves greedy.

Wanting a Free College Education somehow isn’t Greedy

No one illustrates this better than the college student.  Fresh out of our public school system.  Where they’ve learned the evils of capitalism.  The fairness of socialism.  And the benevolence of Big Government.  These kids are all about equality.  Egalitarianism.  And sticking it to Big Business and corporate America.  All while enjoying their products.  Cell phones.  Cars.  Clothes.  iPods.  Air conditioning.  Heat.  The Internet.  Reality television.  To name but a few.

But life isn’t fair.  And favors the rich unfairly.  So they become politically active.  Vote the anti-capitalistic ticket.  And participate in the occasional protest.  Making it ever harder for Mom and Dad to foot the bill for their carefree life of self-discovery.  By voting for the party that raises their taxes.  But these kids don’t care.  Mostly because they don’t have a clue about the things they’re protesting.  But protesting is fun.  So they protest.  And, of course, because greed is bad.

But greed is relative.  And somehow their greed isn’t greed.  First of all, they’re going to college.  Why?  To make a lot of money.  Because they’re greedy and want the latest cell phone, car, style, iPod, etc.  They want all the best toys.  And party at all the best clubs.  But having that kind of money often requires a college education.  Which isn’t cheap.  And requires some sizeable student loans.  That they don’t want to repay.  Because it isn’t fair to burden new college graduates with the cost of their education.  And yet somehow this greed (wanting a free college education) isn’t greedy.

It’s Easy to Think of the Righteousness of Egalitarianism when you’re not Paying the Bills

College kids may think their parents are greedy for not wanting to pay more taxes.  For not believing in the righteousness of egalitarianism.  Like they do.  Then again, it’s easy to think that way when you’re not paying the bills.  It’s a whole different story when your bills don’t go to Mom and Dad anymore.

And if you got a high-paying job with that college degree you may lose even more of your brotherly love.  When you start paying your own bills.  You discover you can’t have everything you ever wanted simply by having a college degree.  And you make an even more startling discovery.  The more you earn the more the government takes in taxes.  And that just isn’t fair.  Now that you’re on the other side of that income gap.



Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,