The Credit Rating Agencies wanted Serious Spending Cuts and our Glorious Government Delivered
It was scary. We stared into the abyss. We stood at the edge of the world as we knew it. With one foot held up midstride, dangling precariously over the void. Ready to tumble forward into the chasm of fiscal demise. And then something happened. Congress compromised. There would be more debt. There would be more spending. And they restored our financial house to order. We could put that foot down on terra firma. Everything was going to be all right. Like it was before. Hallelujah (see U.S. Debt Rating: Economists Wait to Hear From S&P by Susanna Kim posted 8/3/2011 on ABC News).
Now that President Obama has signed the debt ceiling deal and averted a default, economists are waiting to see if ratings agency Standard and Poor’s will downgrade the nation’s credit rating…
At stake in all this is not only interest rates the US must pay on its $14.4 trillion debt, but a host of rates for consumers, from mortgages to car loans to credit cards. A downgrade of US debt would cause interest rates of all kinds to edge up and that would cost the US and consumers billions of dollars. The stock market plunged yesterday partly on worries about this possibility.
What a horrible fate this would have been. God bless Barak Obama, Harry Reid, John Boehner and everyone else that did such an extraordinary job of saving us from this fate. The credit rating agencies wanted to see some serious spending cuts. And by God if that isn’t what our glorious government gave them. Moody’s and Fitch have already given us the good news. We’re still AAA with them. Just waiting on Standard and Poor’s. If they still like us we’re golden.
No spending cuts, no Deficit Reduction and no Credit Downgrade, were they Lying?
The only problem with this is that it is all bull [deleted expletive] (see Spending Cuts Seen as Step, Not as Cure by Binyamin Appelbaum posted 8/2/2011 on The New York Times).
There is something you should know about the deal to cut federal spending that President Obama signed into law on Tuesday: It does not actually reduce federal spending.
By the end of the 10-year deal, the federal debt would be much larger than it is today.
Indeed, both the government and its debts will continue to grow faster than the American economy, primarily because the new law does not address federal spending on health care.
Well how can this be? More spending?!? And not just a little but a lot. So much that it will grow faster than the economy. But they told us they made real spending cuts. That they made some real deficit reduction. Are you telling me that our government lied to us?
Stabilizing that [debt] ratio would require about $4 trillion in cuts over the next decade, according to a number of independent analysts. That is also the target that S.&P. declared the nation must meet, and it was the goal of the “grand bargain” that Mr. Obama tried to reach last month with Speaker John A. Boehner.
The deal they reached instead contains cuts of at least $2.1 trillion over the next 10 years. By the end of that period, the federal debt could equal as much as 80 percent of economic activity, and rising.
Guess so. We barely made half of the recommended cuts and two of the agencies already gave us their blessings. Which begs the question was all that fear mongering of the debt downgrade just bull you-know-what? Just a trick to raise the debt ceiling? I mean, this deal should have triggered the credit downgrade. It doesn’t cut spending or reduce the deficit. So how can it be the end of the world as we know it one minute and then credit rating bliss the next? Because nothing changed. Something fishy here.
With the Spending Crisis over, now comes More Spending
All right, so the spending cuts were only phantom spending cuts. Just designed to fool the American people so the government can do what they do best. What they always planned to do. Even though the credit rating agencies said we can’t keep doing it. Spend with reckless abandon (see Compromise achieved, reform’s the next chapter by Timothy Geithner posted 8/2/2011 on The Washington Post).
The agreement creates room for the private sector to continue to grow, without the threat of default and the burden of higher interest rates…
And by locking in long-term savings, Congress will have more room in the fall to pass additional short-term measures to strengthen the economy — such as extending the payroll tax cut, which provides an average of a thousand dollars to the after-tax incomes of working Americans; extending unemployment benefits; and financing infrastructure investments. After all, strengthening growth and putting more Americans back to work are among the most important things we can do to improve our fiscal situation today and over the long term.
This is like a chain smoker who just got the scare of his life. A bad lung X-ray that could be cancer. Only to find out later that it wasn’t cancer. He feels so good that he lights up to celebrate his good health.
The government has already tried every Keynesian stimulus in the book. A trillion dollar stimulus bill. Subsidies for green energy (the economy of the future). Tax credits. Shovel ready jobs. None of this helped the economy. It just gave us a spending crisis that added so much debt that the credit agencies are threatening to downgrade the U.S. bond rating. Additional spending is not going to improve our credit worthiness. In fact, it will do that other thing. The opposite thing. It will make it much, much worse. How can they not see this? Was I the only one paying attention these past weeks?
When the Market Corrects things get Better; when the Government Corrects you get Double-Dip Recession
So it’s been all smoke and mirrors. So what? So they like to spend. But their spending stimulates, does it not? They’re investing in the future. To win the future. Like green energy. The economy of the future. They’re pouring money into this to create jobs and stimulate the economy. And imagine how bad things would be if they didn’t do this. Instead of a double-dip recession we may be in a triple-dip recession. The recession could be one dip worse, then, couldn’t it?
Yeah, that’s a joke. The economy is horrible despite everything they’ve tried. Or perhaps it’s horrible because of everything they’ve tried. Spending for the sake of spending hasn’t produced any results yet. Just take a look at the Chevy Volt. The car that was to lead GM back from the abyss. And change the American automobile industry. The Obama administration was going all in on this car. Even ponying up $7,500 in tax credits per car just to make people buy these things. But apparently the people don’t like the Chevy Volt. Because they’re not buying them. Even with a federal gift of $7,500 to sweeten the deal (see Chevy Volt: Still Not Selling by Jonathan V. Last posted 8/3/2011 on the weekly Standard).
The July sales numbers are out and the Chevy Volt continues to electrify (get it?) the country. GM sold … 125 Volts last month!
Way back in March I made fun of the Volt for selling 281 units in February. Turns out, February was a good month. But wait, there’s more! GM says they’re going to increase production to 5,000 Volts per month in order to keep up with demand. You see, they claim that the reason the Volt isn’t selling is that they can’t keep enough cars on the lot. A GM spokeswoman recently claimed that they are “virtually sold out.” Which is virtually true. Mark Modica called around his local Chevy dealers and found plenty of Volts waiting for an environmentally conscious driver to bring them home.
These numbers are so bad they’re embarrassing. And building 5,000 units to meet a 125 unit demand? You can tell the government is calling the shots at GM.
This is what happens when government starts running automobile companies. They destroy automobile companies. And wastes tax money. They’ll keep raising taxes (and borrowing money) so they can ‘invest’ in jobs. Creating jobs where people build things that nobody buys. This is how the best and brightest tweak the economy. Use Keynesian stimulus to correct for ‘market inefficiencies’. Which in Washington is when people don’t spend their money ‘correctly’.
Of course, when the market corrects things get better. When the government corrects you get a double-dip recession.
The Obama Administration did some serious Fear Peddling to get the Debt Ceiling Raised
The Obama administration did some serious fear peddling to get the debt ceiling raised. First they tried to scare everyone that the government would default on their debt obligations. When it was pointed out that there was some $200 billion of tax revenue coming in monthly they changed their story.
Then they tried to scare old people by saying they couldn’t send out Social Security checks. When it was pointed out that Social Security Trust Fund was full of treasury securities (i.e., IOUs) that could be converted into cash without any impact on the debt ceiling they changed their story.
Then they tried to scare everyone that if they didn’t reduce the deficit with a balanced approach (new taxes and spending cuts, but mostly new taxes) the credit rating agencies would downgrade the U.S. AAA debt rating. So far that hasn’t happened. Despite there being no deficit reduction.
Well, they got their debt increase. They may have been less than honest but they got it. And what are they going to do with that additional $2.4 trillion? Why, build more Chevy Volts, I guess. And other winning-the-future job-creating Keynesian stimulus spending. Because it’s worked so well these past few years.
Tags: AAA, Chevy Volt, create jobs, credit downgrade, credit rating agencies, debt, debt ceiling, deficit, deficit reduction, double-dip recession, fear peddling, GM, green energy, Keynesian, Keynesian stimulus, new taxes, Obama, raise the debt ceiling, raising taxes, recession, spending, spending crisis, spending cuts, stimulate the economy, stimulus, subsidies, tax credits